Water Heater Showdown: Tank vs. Tankless

Ah, the joys of hot water! We often take it for granted until our water heater throws in the towel. When it’s time to replace that old, inefficient water heater, you’re faced with a big decision: tank or tankless? Read on as we break down the pros and cons of both options, helping you make an informed choice for your home and family’s hot water needs.

The Tank Water Heater

Let’s start with the classic—the tank water heater. This appliance has been a staple in homes for decades. Here’s what you need to know.

Pros

Cost-Effective: Tank water heaters are generally more affordable upfront than tankless, making them an attractive choice for budget-conscious homeowners.
Easy Installation: If you’re replacing an old tank water heater, installing a new one is often straightforward and usually fits into the same space and uses the same connections.
Reliable: Tank water heaters are known for their durability and longevity when properly maintained.
Gas or Electric: Get the right fit for your home’s needs with both gas and electric models available. In general, an electric water heater will have a lower purchase price, but a gas system will heat water much faster.

Cons

Limited Efficiency: These systems constantly heat and reheat water in the tank, even when you‘re not using hot water. This results in energy waste and higher utility bills.
Limited Hot Water: Once the tank runs out of hot water, you’ll need to wait for it to heat up again, which can be frustrating during peak usage times.
Space Requirements: Tank water heaters take up valuable space in your home, and if you need more hot water for your household, you’ll need a larger tank, which can be a space challenge.

The Tankless Water Heater

Now, let’s take a look at the more tech-savvy option—the tankless water heater.

Pros

Energy Efficiency: Tankless water heaters heat water on demand, which means they only use energy when you need hot water. This leads to energy savings and a lower utility bill!
Unlimited Hot Water: Say goodbye to cold showers! Tankless heaters provide a continuous hot water supply, ideal for households with high hot water demands.
Space-Saving: Tankless water heaters are compact and can be installed in smaller spaces, freeing up room in your home.
Longevity: When properly maintained, a tankless water heater can last 15-20 years or more, while a tank water heater’s lifespan averages 8-12 years.
Gas or Electric: Tankless water heaters also come in gas or electric models to ensure a perfect fit for all home needs. Electric units are, on average, more energy efficient, while gas water heaters tend to be more cost-efficient due to lower costs of natural gas and propane.

Cons

Higher Initial Cost: Energy Star-certified tankless water heaters can be pricier to purchase and install, but they may pay for themselves over time through energy savings.
Installation Complexity: Installing a tankless water heater may require changes to your home’s gas or electrical systems, which could increase installation costs.
Maintenance: While they have a longer lifespan, tankless heaters may require periodic maintenance to prevent scaling and other issues.

Choosing the Right Size

Now that you understand the differences between a tank and tankless water heater, what size is right for you? There are a few key things to consider:

Number of people in home
Daily hot water usage
Types of household appliances
Local plumbing codes

Learn more in this episode of Goettl Homeowner Tips on YouTube.

Choosing between a tank and tankless water heater depends on your specific needs and budget. If you prioritize lower upfront costs and have space to spare, a tank water heater might be a suitable choice. However, if energy efficiency, unlimited hot water, and saving space are your priorities, then a tankless water heater is the way to go.

Water (heater) you waiting for?

Ready to upgrade your water heater? Contact Goettl today for expert advice and professional installation services. Make the switch to a more efficient and reliable hot water system.

find a location near you

Testimonials

What Our Customers Say About Us

Terrie F. Reno

This is to let you that your Service technician Dan Weinhold is one of a kind. He is professional, respectful yet friendly and shows…

Renae K. Phoenix

Two gentlemen came out. One to check out our plumbing and one to check out our air conditioner. Both were yearly maintenance check ups. The…

Marshall C. Phoenix

My experience with Goettl today was exceptional. My technician Ron was professional, courteous, knowledgeable and the installation of my…

Renee B. Phoenix

Chris came and checked the sewer pipe. He found the pipe collapsed. He was very professional and explained in detail the damage to the…

Abhi M. Austin

Great service from Daniel Ramirez. He fixed my kitchen water issue very quickly. He was very professional, approachable. Highly…

James B. Las Vegas

I had Tim come to our home to do a maintenance and I must say just wow! We have used Goettl for years and never had an experience like…

Elaine E. San Antonio

Today Junior Gonzalez with Goettl Plumbing provided the best service for me ever. He installed a new emergency shutoff valve for the water…

Hermelinda R. Las Vegas

STEVO AND CHRIS DID AN AMAZING JOB WITH MY PLUMBING INSPECTION TODAY I DIDNT KNOW MY WATER HEATER WAS ACTIVELY LEAKING AND CAUSING WATER…

Ruth R. Las Vegas

I had a great experience with Kevin at Goett!! I been dealing with really bad allergies, and Kevin took the time to address my concerns. He…

King B. Austin

Brent was awesome. He quickly identified our leak and was able to make the appropriate repairs. Brent was very thorough and took the time…

Susan B. Las Vegas

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I had a wonderful experience with Goett!! Kevin and Armando were both amazing throughout the entire process of…

Gail G. Las Vegas

uJoe from Goettl did a wonderful job replaceing my a/c fan motor by himself. My attic is an extremely tight space and overwhelmingly hot…

Dan R. Reno

Today, Dan came and performed our fall maintenance on our HVAC system. He let us know when he was on his way, showed up when he said and…

Sabrina M. Las Vegas

Myles was amazing!!, In getting my fall service done on my air unit Myles suggested a start assist to help with the hard draw on the power…

Tavin R. Las Vegas

All concerns have been met with in person customer service at my home. My system went down and they were there same day installing a new…

Nicole M. Las Vegas

The home warranty company sent two different companies to our home with a zero percent success rate. Rather than continue with inadequate…

Ashton C. Phoenix

Someone give Zach a raise and promotion immediately! Yesterday we had a small gas leak from our water heater. My grandma and I wanted piece…

Leah S. Phoenix

We had such a great experience with Jarrett at Goettl Air! He came out to service and inspect our AC unit, and we were incredibly impressed…

Devon H. Tucson

Hector was amazing, we originally had him coming out to replace our UV light but our ac shut off like it has been for the last 3 months at…

Sharon S. Austin

We had Goettl AC and Heating come to check out our AC this morning. Luke arrived on time in a company uniform. He gave our AC a complete…

Angela B. Las Vegas

We received about 7 quotes for our AC unit that wasn't blowing cold air anymore. Our unit is 15 years old. They all diagnosed it and told…

James S. Austin

These guys are very, very professional, and I have nothing but a five-star rating for GOETTL Air Conditioning and Plumbing. I had been…

Heather M. Las Vegas

I had another plumbing company perform a maintenance flush on my water heater, and they told me it was a “ticking time bomb” and needed to…

Ed O. Phoenix

Jacob is an excellent technician. He is very thorough and answered all my questions. I had previously purchased a water heater from Goettl…

Damien B. Las Vegas

We were honestly so desperate when our AC went out during the summer. Our little boy was having a hard time and we really needed a solution…

Maryann K. Reno

We had two air conditioning units serviced for routine maintenance, and I couldn’t have been more impressed with the two technicians…

Donald C. Las Vegas

Our service technician Armando was knowledgeable pleasant and very easy to understand. He clearly explained what we needed and was very…

Thomas H. Austin

Brent did great work and was very pleasant. He made sure I understood what he thought was needed to solve my problem with a tankless water…

Julie M. Austin

All the guys that have come to help us with our 20+ years of grease plugged pipes have been great. Patient and doing their best to help us…

Carla S. Las Vegas

I contacted Goettl for a second opinion inregards to my toilets needing to be rebuilt and my water heater needing repairs. Zach came to…

Traci L. Phoenix

My ac unit went out and it was in the 90s in my house , I take care of my grandson who is 5 and special needs and can't be in the heat and…

Gabrielle C. Phoenix

Lupe was absolutely amazing! Our AC went out, and he came out to our house at 9:00 at night to help get it back up and running. He was…

Yenny C. Phoenix

The service provided was exceptional. A while ago, I reached out to the company for assistance with a few matters. Max Villegas was the…

Kat M. San Antonio

I’m extremely grateful to Chris and his professional team for finally solving my heating and air concerns. My home had an initial design…

Paul R. San Antonio

We bought our house last year. We weren't sure if the previous owner was keeping up with the AC maintenance so we had Goettl come out and…

Mattify C. Reno

Within the past month, I had 2 other unsuccessful diagnostic tests on my air conditioner from different places – but I finally found…

Jim G. Las Vegas

Angel was a pleasure to deal with; knowledgeable, efficient, fast, and extremely personable. After having explained our options thoroughly…

Alyssa L. Reno

Chris was fantastic! Spent ample time answering all of my questions and problem solving next steps for our system. We prioritized which…

Melissa M. Las Vegas

Angel was calm and professional. He understood I have trauma from past technicians with other companies and took me through step by step…

Martha W. Reno

We had a fantastic experience with everyone who worked on installing our new hvac duct system. From the knowledge and experience of the…

Nicki T. Austin

Great experience from start to finish. Scheduling was easy, communication was clear, and they arrived right on time. Jarod W. handled the…

Harlan R. Tucson

These guys were amazing. Our hot water heater broke in the middle of the day. I went on several local websites and requested service right…

Ricardo M. San Antonio

Jason the technician is a master class technician who thoroughly assessed our units operational effectiveness and efficiency. He inspected…

Jeremy M. Austin

Brent was very helpful and honest with me when he discovered both my household and city shutoff valves needed replacing, which required…

Marlo W. Las Vegas

After my 24 year old A/C recently went out I immediately called Goettl. As an Arizona transplant I am so glad we have them here in NV, as…

Joseph M. Phoenix

I had a new born baby a few days before but when I got home my home wasn’t cooling down. I had called Goettl at 7pm at night and Sammy had…

CP C. Tucson

Our water bill reflected higher usage than normal. We had a leak but had no idea where it was. Called Goettl, & tech Caleb showed up. He…

Kristina K. Las Vegas

David came to perform a rejuvenation on our HVAC units, we have two. One of them was not kicking on causing half of our home to be…

Douglas A. San Antonio

Christen and Melvin we very knowledgeable and professional. They took the time to explain what they were doing and what the findings…

Alex R. Austin

It was an almost 12 hour job, and throughout, Mr. Herrera’s competency and professionalism were reassuring. As a teacher, whose…

Derek D. San Antonio

The Goettl team was a pleasure to work with. Everyone I came in contact with was professional and very pleasant. They were able to diagnose…

Bruce S. Tucson

OUTSTANDING job by the Goettl plumbing team! From the initial estimate to scheduling and the final installation, every step of the process…

Janet E. Tucson

Immediate response to my call for air conditioning service. Showed up promptly. Technicians are professional and quick to identify the…

Christina C. Phoenix

We cannot say enough good things about our experience! When our AC went out, Nick came out late at night without hesitation to help us. He…

Aj G. Phoenix

Oh my gosh I really love this guy because Donovan. Took his time on explaining everything to us I think this company is honest and caring…

Rick G. Las Vegas

Tristan and Steve replaced 2 bathroom faucets for me today. They were courteous, professional and very respectful of our home. Faucets are…

Jmelissa W. San Antonio

Working with Goettl was a pleasure from start to finish. From the young lady who took my call requesting a quote. Peter came out and was…

Erin S. Phoenix

Ronald came by on a Sunday after our A/C died. Although the part that was needed had to be ordered, he was very efficient and diagnosed the…

Deja D. Tucson

Caleb was fabulous! He was extremely knowledgeable and explained the process to us we didn’t feel rushed and we didn’t feel pressured at…

Ken J. Las Vegas

My overall experience, I would give an A+. The product is great. Everyone who I dealt with on the replacement were extremely professional…

Gilbert W. Reno

Anthony Morgan was our Technician. He arrived on time and always made sure we understood what was happening. Was very patient and diagnosed…

Steve R. Las Vegas

Kevin was super star ⭐️. He showed up looking very professional. He was well spoken . What I mean is he had manners, was respectful. He…

Kayleen M. Phoenix

Kellen our tech was awesome!! We had our entire HVAC system and air ducts cleaned, and the experience was fantastic! He was extremely…

Gary D. Reno

I was very pleased with Goettl Air Conditioning & Plumbing, Andrew the technician was very quick to zero in on the problem and had several…

Jeff P. Tucson

On time – the service provider was courteous, knowledgeable and thorough. He went back and completed a final check after he was done – I…

Zuleika S. Las Vegas

What a great team at Goettl ! Martelvious was quick to do a same day inspection due to leaking found on the side of the house. Jeff came…

Bobby B. San Antonio

Outstanding service! My technician, Juan, clearly explained my plumbing issues and how best to resolve those problems. I was able to ask…

Kevin U. Las Vegas

I had an excellent experience with Goettl, and I want to give a huge thank you to Jeremy Estrella for the outstanding service. From the…

Valerie V. Phoenix

We had a great experience with Goettl! Our AC stopped working during the Arizona heat, and the technician was professional, knowledgeable…

Michael G. Reno

I just wanted to tell how impressed i was with Joe from boston professional and thorough diagnostic and repair of our system. We lost ac…

Logan H. Phoenix

Sam has exceeded my expectations. I was skeptical of an HVAC company servicing my house and taking advantage of me. I feel like Sam has…

Debbie F. Phoenix

Excellent service. Your installers were very efficient and professional. They kept me informed of the changes they were going to have to…

Sean M. Phoenix

Deano, Darnell & Jabari were all amazing to work with! AC went out – had an appointment in 24 hours. Once we identified I needed a new unit…

Sarah I. Phoenix

A few years ago, we purchased an AC unit from Goettl that wasn’t turning on. I called them for service, and three days later, a technician…

Ronnie J. Phoenix

5 star service from our Tech Zach who assisted with diagnosing and remediating slow draining sinks and shower whistling noise. He arrived…

Erica S. Phoenix

I had a great experience with Sam! He was professional, honest, and responsive from start to finish. He arrived on time, quickly diagnosed…

Nancy R. Las Vegas

Josias is amazing. Explained what was going on. Was very honest about what is going on and options to help support the system. Got it up…

Barb L. Phoenix

My a/c started blowing hot at 4:00. I called Goettl at 4:30. They said a tech would arrive between 7:00 & 9:00. At 8:50 Hunter called to…

Joseph M. Las Vegas

The team that came over to help us attain a new AC unit was above and beyond the best experience I have ever had The individuals Gabriel…

Josie P. Phoenix

Our air conditioner was not cooling. We called Goettl since they had installed our AC system 7 years ago. Service technician Christian…

Daniel V. Tucson

Troy initially came out to assess the problem we were experiencing from a 2 year old unit installed by Chas Roberts. We made the mistake of…

Audrey W. Phoenix

I had my yearly air conditioner maintenance performed by Goettl this year, I feel it was a more honest assessment than what a different air…

Raquel L. San Antonio

My downstairs AC unit kept shutting off repeatedly and I had to keep suctioning the condensation line with my shop vac just to get it…

Yolanda C. Reno

I cannot say enough great things about Matt and Jake. My mother in laws house had a major issue with the AC. Their company got us in right…

Cathren S. Austin

I have been using Goettl A/C and heating now for a few years now, and have been very please with their professionalism. They truly care…

Audrey B. Phoenix

Christian was absolutely amazing and has my AC working like a champ! He was very knowledgeable, kind, and patient with all the questions I…

Big R. Las Vegas

Complete system install. Condensor/compressor, evaporator coil, and furnace. Not cheap,(got similar/ same quotes from smaller companies)but…

Ralph M. Phoenix

The Goettl team that worked on the installation of the AC and repair of the. cooler On my home-were Cesar, Adrian,Rhino And Kevin. I was…

Ben K. Reno

Great experience with Nevada Heating. Came back from a week-long trip to find my house was 90 degrees at 3am. I reached out through the…

Joscelyn I. Phoenix

I had an outstanding experience with Goettl and highly recommend them! From start to finish, the team was professional, courteous, and…

Melissa M. Tucson

Hector from Goettl Air Conditioning and Plumbing provided an outstanding service experience. He was extremely professional, knowledgeable…

Jill D. Las Vegas

I cannot express enough thanks to Goettl. There was a bit of confusion with the first tech but then Joe picked up the ball and he was so…

Marilee H. Phoenix

We had a baby shower scheduled on the same day as our anual check up. It was a foos thing because some of our components were compromised…

Jeni F. Las Vegas

I would give 10 Stars 🌟 if possible. My service was exceptional. Dammar needs a shout out and a raise/bonus. It is extremely hot but he…

Delene B. Reno

Quinn did our service, he arrived during the time frame we were told, he was kind, understanding, and completely respectful to us, our home…

Valentina P. Las Vegas

TIM IS THE BEST HANDS DOWN. I Had the best experience with Goettl, ac unit died and I had called many different companies to get it checked…

Braiden S. Phoenix

From the first rep arriving to the finish of the installation this process was customer focused and extremely professional. You pay for…

Chuck L. Las Vegas

I am proud to write this review. I had two AC units replaced by Goettl. Four gentleman with three trucks arrived and within nine hours…

Scotty B. Austin

Had been working with another company in Austin and brought Goettl in for a second opinion and haven’t ever looked back. Jarod guided us…

Greg A. Phoenix

I had Goettl replace my entire split A/C system. they gave me an estimate late in the evening on June 10th 2026 and they completed the…